diff --git a/app/Http/Controllers/V3/Dashboard/RoadObservationController.php b/app/Http/Controllers/V3/Dashboard/RoadObservationController.php
index 00b39cab..8fc65f1f 100644
--- a/app/Http/Controllers/V3/Dashboard/RoadObservationController.php
+++ b/app/Http/Controllers/V3/Dashboard/RoadObservationController.php
@@ -172,20 +172,22 @@ class RoadObservationController extends Controller
 
     public function referList(RoadObserved $roadObserved): JsonResponse
     {
-        $referList = [];
         $data = RoadObservationHistory::query()
             ->where('road_observation_histories.id', $roadObserved->id)
-            ->where('action', '=', 'refer')->get();
+            ->where('action', '=', 'refer')->get([
+                'created_at', 'description', 'from_edareh', 'to_edareh',
+                'from_province', 'to_province', 'user_id'
+            ]);
 
         foreach ($data as $key => $value) {
-            $referList[$key]['from_edareh'] = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->from_edareh)->name_fa;
-            $referList[$key]['to_edareh'] = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->to_edareh)->name_fa;
-            $referList[$key]['from_province'] = Province::query()->find($value->from_province)->name_fa;
-            $referList[$key]['to_province'] = Province::query()->find($value->to_province)->name_fa;
+            $data[$key]->from_edareh = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->from_edareh)->name_fa;
+            $data[$key]->to_edareh = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->to_edareh)->name_fa;
+            $data[$key]->from_province = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->from_province)->name_fa;
+            $data[$key]->to_province = EdarateShahri::query()->find($value->to_province)->name_fa;
             $user = User::query()->find($value->user_id);
-            $referList[$key]['user'] = $user->first_name . ' ' . $user->last_name;
+            $data[$key]->user = $user->first_name . ' ' . $user->last_name;
         }
-        return $this->successResponse($referList);
+        return $this->successResponse($data);
     }
 
     public function restore(RestoreRequest $request, RoadObserved $roadObserved): JsonResponse